In an article published by the Idaho Statesman on April 25th, titled Idaho starts $600-a-week payment, some will get more than jobs paid, journalist Davis Staats, writes, “Some Idahoans still working may resent that they will now be making less than their laid-off colleagues and that the payments seem to provide an incentive not to work.” Now I know that this is a nod at a potentially popular sentiment and not necesarily a personal belief held of this particular journalist but, as someone who is currently making more on unemployment than I was as a bartender, I resent that statement.
I resent that statement for so many reasons. First and foremost, it is completely accurate. With the CARESAct, I am currently making three times what I was while working in the service industry AND I don’t have deal with drunk people. I also don’t have to stay up until 3:30am to close the bar and feel like trash the entire next day. I don’t have to stand on my feet for 12 hours on a slow Sunday trying desperately to fill my time with bullshit side work to combat going crazy with boredom, a depressing sense of purposelessness or even just to avoid a manager who likes to say, “If you have time to lean, you have time to clean.” Well now I have time to lean AND I have time to clean and the inside of my own refrigerator has never looked better.
I am on a regular sleep cycle and I eat like a human being again- whole meals, sitting down! No longer do I consume calories, while standing, huddled in a corner at 11:30pm, shoving chicken strips furiously into my mouth because only have 5 minutes and part of my compensation is a shift meal, plus our ranch is really good.
Aside from the grind of working in the service industry and the physical and relational toll that any jobs takes on ones life, this goes deeper. Not only am I now making more money and better able to care for myself but while on unemployment, I am actually confident I can pay my bills this month and for the next six, or as long as my claim lasts, or COVID related extensions are approved. Put that next to the up and down nature of earning income in the service industry, in which making rent is dependent on getting scheduled for the busy shifts that week, what the weather is like because people don’t like to walk from their cares to a building in the rain or how generous people are feeling based on the alignment of the stars, yeah, I’ll take unemployment.
How dare us, right? How dare us chronically underpaid, typically uninsured people not want to go back to our mostly shitty jobs? How completely irresponsible of us to want to work less hard for money and security? Please! To the self-righteous- speak now or forever hold your peace. Please introduce me to the people you know who you’ve heard say, “well I could have take that promotion but that would mean working less for more money, and I just, um…. don’t feel like thats right!” Wouldn’t you look at them like they were bat shit crazy? Isn’t that counter to the American dream? Isn’t that what we do here, in America? Don’t we build laters so that we can scale the financial walls that grow taller every quarter around us, in order to “give our children the opportunities we never had?” Aren’t we given full lisence to step on anyone who gets in our way, to nail their limbs between rungs on that later, if necessary just so we can climb it a little faster?
Please, America, show me examples of leaders in the public and private sectors who were like, “You know what, I’m going to grind this one out, not take big business campaign contributions and build a campaign on small individual donations and my policy platform.” Oh wait, ahem, we did and people though that was weird and didn’t vote for him! Show me some major corporation executives from places like Amazon and Fedex whose workers, are going on strike TODAY say, “you know what I am going to work harder for less money so that I can pay my workers a livable wage, because people ARE more important than profits and I do realize that our survival depends on our workforce and oh hey, I don’t really need that 3rd vacation home I was planning on building this year and you know what, I’ll even through in the yatch, because I wasn’t using it very much and it does consume an irresponsible amount of fuel.” What about the retail entrepreneur who took production to places like China and Indonesia, was your goal to work harder for less money? No I didn’t think so.
All the talented baby boomers and tech companies who have, over the past half century, taken your skills to the private sector so that you could capitalize on your education and your talents rather than put them toward our public systems, you can blame yourselves for a slow and ill functioning unemployment system that is standing between people and their rent money today. The point is, it is okay for the greedy, for the capitalistic, even for the well-intentioned middle income American dreamer, to want to work less and earn more money but it is not ok for the working poor to want the same. “Stay in your lane servant, how dare you discover how good life can be with a little financial security and REM sleep.”
I resent this statement because we, the unemployed, know that this is temporary and we don’t know if we will have jobs to go back to. We can see the end of our benefits, it is posted right there on our weekly claimant portal webpage, but we cannot see or know what business will be like when we have our jobs back. If we were barely making it before, in a booming economy, the outlook is not good. Our survival this winter may depend on how much we save now. As a country, we don’t know the economic impacts yet. We don’t know how much faith people will have to even go out in public or spend money, especially on things like going out to eat or drink or play. Lets be honest, how many of you are chomping at the bit for some private suite karaoke and a margarita right now? Okay, maybe wrong question to prove my point, the way I put there, it does sound pretty fun. However, and unfortunately the threat of spread is still real and will be for the next year to a year and half, as hard as that is to admit at this point.
I resent the original statement for one more reason. That is that it implied that someone like me, a bartender, is a “colleague” to someone who stocks grocieries at Winco. How dare you? If it wasn’t clear before it is now, the bar business is non-essential, its basically bullshit and we know it; we actually need that person to stock those groceries. And yeah, we service industry people, us drunk writers, druggie drag queens, broke comics, tatted painting revolutionaries, we are now making more money than those workers are AND we are sheltered from risk of catching and spreading the coronavirus. Do we deserve that? Do we deserve to get paid more and to be safer, yeah and guess wha so do they. Are they resentful of us, I hope not, it doesn’t serve them. I think the people who are resentful are not the working poor but the people who depend on the working poor for their above average lifestyle but don’t want to admit it, less they have to pay them more.
See, poor people aren’t like that as a rule and right now, the working ones are all probably too tired to be resentful at all. If there are some of you working for shit wages out there who think like this, that sucks; you have bought into the scheme of the ultra rich which keeps people competing for “scarce” resources when the reality is that we live in the richest country in the world and there is truly enough. If we weren’t competing or resenting, or being told we were resenting, we might organize. Remember the stock market and big business are being floated through this at a much higher rate than the average American. Here’s some rough math to put it into perspective. Those of us on unemployment are making on average, half year’s salary at about the rate of about 30,000 per year. So if a grocery stocker is making less than 30,000 per year, which they probably are here in Idaho, maybe that’s the problem.
To imply that the people still working low wage jobs would be resentful of other people also at the bottom of the pay scale shows a lack of understanding for the way we operate and is honestly the most offensive part of this statement. Give us a little credit, its unlikely we are as petty as you. The people who live and work in my income bracket, my friends, my colleagues, my fellow artists and entertainers, we are the people who help each other. We make meals for each other and organize food drives. We watch each others kids and swap clothes to refresh our wardrobes. We help each other move and listen to each other stories. We know how stretch a food budget with spices and beans. Okay, maybe some of us hole in in depression and self-loathing too, but we are free to dream. I don’t believe the majority of the working poor are resentful that other poor people are now a little less poor for a very short period of time. If I’m not incentivized to go back to work it’s not because I see a future for myself in the unemployment biz, where I can do nothing but flit my days away writing angry opinion articles; it’s because the incentives at my work are cocktails and curly fries.